View Lost Cats Near Menomonee Falls, WI

Mariah is Missing in Menomonee Falls, WI

Share on

Status

LOST

Date Last Seen

March 28, 2026

Location Last Seen

Menomonee Falls, WI 53051

Nearest Landmark

Pilgrim Rd. And Appleton Ave.

Name

Mariah

Sex

Female

PawBoost ID

72856012

Species

Cat

Description

Fawn in color, long-hair and possibly matted.

Message from Owner

She's a night owl and her nickname is 3rd Shift. She is sweet but very skittish. Snuck out and was seen on cameras for days eating and drinking. When we'd open the door she'd run away. Then we started to see a racoon and an opossum eatting her food, but no Mariah

Facebook Community Response

Sue M.
4 weeks ago
Hope u find your kitty❤️ Put food near your door. Place a baby monitor and/or home security camera near the food so you can hear/see when your cat is there eating and go and get him/her. Check MADACC and other humane societies. Post on Lost Cats of Wisconsin. Keep checking each day! Check under bushes and other places in your yard and neighborhood to see if he is hiding there. Cats become scared and won't come when called. Don't give up. People find their cats months later. My friend found their cat 3 months after it got lost. It was hiding under a bush in the neighborhood, not coming when called and acting feral… very scared! Prayers! Hope u find your kitty❤️ Put food near your door. Place a baby monitor and/or home security camera near the food so you can hear/see when your cat is there eating and go and get him/her. Check MADACC and other humane societies. Post on Lost Cats of Wisconsin. Keep checking each day! Check under bushes and other places in your yard and neighborhood to see if he is hiding there. Cats become scared and won't come when called. Don't give up. People find their cats months later. My friend found their cat 3 months after it got lost. It was hiding under a bush in the neighborhood, not coming when called and acting feral… very scared! Prayers! Also recheck the house??? Also recheck the house???
Reply
Wendy W.
4 weeks ago
Julie Ehlers I placed out her blanket last night. I have 2 other cats that actually go outside and come back. I was hoping that they'd find her and bring her back....but nope.
Reply
Wendy W.
4 weeks ago
Lauri Ruelle-Teriaca not yet, I had her blanket outside for starters.
Reply
Lauri R.
4 weeks ago
Any updates? 🤞🏼🐾🐾❤️
Reply
Julie E.
4 weeks ago
Try setting up a live trap with smelly canned cat food and a blanket or bed that has your and her scent on it, put up flyers with her picture and to contact you if seen. Check your local shelter in person at least once a week. Don't give up it can take weeks or months.
Reply
Wendy W.
4 weeks ago
Debra Bontrager thank you for taking the time to post this guide! I think she also may be under some patio furniture that is covered up since the fall.
Reply
Wendy W.
4 weeks ago
Dawn Wait thank you for taking the time to post these helpful suggestions!
Reply
Dawn W.
4 weeks ago
My heart goes out to you. I have been through it myself. Here are some tips I've put together over years of working with rescue. * Don't wait for him/her to come home. Yes, he/she may do that, but most cats are scared and go hiding in small places, mostly close to home, a few houses or a block away. (They can go a few miles if chased or desperate, mostly in desperation looking for water and food.) They hide under cars, decks, patios, porches, in sheds, drain pipes, stairs, window wells, garages, bushes, woods, up trees, roofs, etc. Walk around calling their name, shaking a treat bag or favorite toy with bell. Carry smelly food to encourage them if scared and hiding. Listen very, very carefully for low meows. Use a flashlight to catch and reflect their eyes. A good time to go looking is twilight and very early morning/pre-dawn, when it’s quiet and calm so they may feel safer to come out and it’s also feeding time. * Talk to and alert everyone you know and that lives in your vicinity, as well as local businesses. Notify and check with shelters/humane societies (both HAWS for Waukesha county & MADACC for Milwaukee county) and local veterinary offices. Post on and check lost sites, such as Lost Cats of Wisconsin (file your report there to create your FREE flyer and a post on Pet FBI ), Nextdoor, various community FB pages, Craig's List. Post flyers on corners/posts, in front of your home, and with neighbors, businesses, and anyone in the vicinity. * Put out a carrier or something right outside your door for shelter and safety. Place clothing/blankets with a familiar scent, yours and/or theirs, inside or nearby. * Searching, go out a few blocks, then back close, then out farther and back close. You may miss the cat or the cat may move or may not be meowing. Repeat over and over, looking carefully on the ground for paw prints and for places they might hide. * If you have a garage, leave open with smelly food favorites, water, clothing/blankets with familiar scent, their old litter box in garage. If you have a family dog who is close to the cat, give the dog something with the cat’s scent and then a treat; and then go walking around, watching your dog very carefully. You can even do this with another cat close to home, if you have a cat harness and leash. * Get or borrow a humane live animal trap and set it up with tuna or some other smelly cat food. Be sure to check it frequently. But in extreme weather, do not set it unless you can monitor it constantly and bring in immediately if caught. * And never stop looking! Never give up! Too many give up too soon. It may take weeks or more before you find and/or someone turns in your cat to an animal shelter. Make sure to contact and also GO IN PERSON to your local shelter/humane society (both HAWS & MADACC) to look at all of the cats they have there. Don’t rely on just pictures or the person answering the phone to have all updated info on who they have there. They do their best, but you need to check in person on a regular basis.
Reply
Debra B.
4 weeks ago
I've been through this before. Often they are disoriented and will not come to you even if you call them by name. I've literally had to crawl into crawl spaces under my building and get one of mine. Once he was looking at me through bushes. My flashlight has helped catch his shadow and eye reflections.
Reply

More Lost & Found Pets Near Menomonee Falls, WI

More Lost Pets in Your Area
More Lost Pets in Your Area
More Lost Pets in Your Area
Pawboost White Dog Hero

JOIN THE

RESCUE

SQUAD

The Rescue Squad™ is a group of 7,594,431 pet lovers who have signed up for local lost & found pet alerts.

Join The Rescue Squad™

Contact Owner