View Lost Cats Near Buffalo, NY

Theodore is Missing in Buffalo, NY

Share on

Status

LOST

Date Last Seen

May 10, 2026

Location Last Seen

Buffalo, NY 14216

Nearest Landmark

Commonwealth Ave

Name

Theodore

Sex

Male

PawBoost ID

72868838

Species

Cat

Description

Theo is 12 years old and only 8 pounds with a missing front, canine tooth and small mat on his hip. He is an indoor cat with multiple dog siblings, who adore him and our desperately looking for him. He is likely skittish and even though he is very friendly I’m not sure he will approach a stranger with noises in the neighborhood. I will show up personally for any sightings.

Message from Owner

Theo is an indoor cat and likely skittish. He is very friendly and is just a little guy. He is 8 pounds and has an M on his forehead and bright green eyes. Please contact me if you think you’ve seen him I will show up immediately.

Facebook Community Response

Brittney I.
4 weeks ago
Litter box outside. Plus anything that smells like you. Get some canned salmon. Check any porches or bushes near your residence. Call for them daily and nightly. They know your voice.
Reply
Jim S.
1 month ago
Lin Gebo they dont Go Far ,Keep Looking
Reply
Eileen A.
1 month ago
PLEASE READ IN ENTIRETY AND TO THE END: Your cat is missing, now what should you do? A list of tips to help you find your lost cat. • Most cats do not go far, less than a ¼ of a mile. Most are found close to home or walk back up to the dooyr eventually. We have to say “most” for a reason. An un-neutered male can have a range of up to 10 miles. A neutered male, that is an outdoor cat, can keep a range of up to five miles. Adults that have been neutered after having been outside for a while (stray etc.) can move farther than expected so it helps if you know your cat's past life if they had one before coming to you. • Cats go into survival mode when lost. They can become lost even from the yard they are used to being in. If they are chased by a dog, another cat, or wild animal even just one yard over they might not know the way back. Indoor-only cats that sneak out have an even harder time knowing where to go. Survival mode means they hide all day, come out only at night and look for a way back in. Usually, after midnight and around 3 am to 5 am seems to be the time they feel safest to move around. Regardless of how friendly your cat is it may not come to you when called. Be prepared for your cat to run even if they would never do that inside. • Check with your neighbors, your cat might be unknowingly trapped in a garage/shed or barn. • Look under porches/decks and sheds. Shine a light and look for eyes reflecting. Even if you call your cat if you see him or her they may not come to you. • Find out if anyone feeds stray cats in your neighborhood. Almost every neighborhood has someone that feeds strays. Talk to them and ask them to keep a watch out for a new cat-eating. • Flyers; are the key to folks knowing your cat is missing and not “just another stray”. For an unknown reason, people see a dog and think “lost” right away. They see a cat and think “stray” and don’t give the cat another thought. Hand out flyers house to house and on poles at intersections. Your immediate neighborhood and then at least 2 streets in each direction to start. Simple and short. Lost cat/number and were lost from with a picture. • Cats have an AMAZING sense of smell and will come back to familiar smells. Place the litter box outside on the front or back porch/deck. Favorite food and change moist food at least once a day. Treats if they like them. A shirt or pillowcase that smells like you with the litter box. • If you have an outside motion light and it goes off at night. Go check your cat is probably out there looking for a way back in. When they cannot get in they will go hide all day again. • Contact your local animal control officer. Even if they only take care of dogs, they will likely take the information and keep it in case anyone calls them with a found cat. Contact local vet offices and leave a flyer there. Be sure to ask to see “Clinic” animals. If your cat is injured and you do not ask to see them you might not be invited to look. • Use social media. You can reach 1000s quickly. Facebook, Twitter, Instagram. Make a Nextdoor lost ad right away. • Research any feral cat colonies in your area. Do not disturb any colonies. Please just leave a note asking them to contact you regarding your lost cat. ALSO, TRY THIS: If your cat has never been outside before, it is best if you get a humane trap. They can be bought at Harbor Freight or Tractor Supply for under $30. Set up near your home AT NIGHT ONLY. Drape with a light tarp (if raining) or towel/t-shirt with your scent. Place very smelly moist cat food in the rear of the trap. Check very early in the morning. Repeat nightly - remove during the day. Cats that have never been outdoors are very frightened and will not move during the day. You may also try to leave your house door open a crack at night while you are home. Your cat may hear your voices and dash in. If you happen to catch a critter or someone else's cat, just release. Don't wait on getting the trap. Your cat will become more feral every day. Good luck.
Reply
Barb E.
1 month ago
Lin Gebo put some unwashed dirty clothes outside and they pick up your scent
Reply
Joan L.
1 month ago
There is a cat that comes on my porch that might be someone's cat. I put cat chow out but it has an attitude and hisses at me for the food. Like where is my food. The feral cats are usually patient.
Reply
.
1 month ago
Kate- Is there any update on Theodore? 🙏🏻
Reply
Margaret S.
1 month ago
Shared
Reply
Joan L.
1 month ago
The picture looks like a big cat but he is said to be small.
Reply
Melissa R.
1 month ago
💔🙏☎️
Reply

More Lost & Found Pets Near Buffalo, NY

More Lost Pets in Your Area
More Lost Pets in Your Area
More Lost Pets in Your Area
Pawboost White Dog Hero

JOIN THE

RESCUE

SQUAD

The Rescue Squad™ is a group of 7,638,733 pet lovers who have signed up for local lost & found pet alerts.

Join The Rescue Squad™

Contact Owner