PawBoost ID or Name

Status

Location

City, Zip, or Address
Distance

Animal

Type

Sex

Sort

Within Past

Lost Cats Database for Bay Shore, NY

Search lost and found cats, as well as other pets, in the Bay Shore area with PawBoost.

115 lost cats in your search

Lost Male Cat last seen Normandy Gardens apmts, Lindenhurst, NY 11757

Reported 2 months ago, updated 2 months ago

Midnight Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72950059


Lindenhurst, NY 11757

He's about 8 or nine now that's the only picture I have of him

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Whalen st, North Babylon, NY 11703

Reported 2 months ago, updated 2 months ago

Nox Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72906315


North Babylon, NY 11703

Two blackish brown spot near ears

View Pet

Lost Unknown Cat last seen Francis Ct, between Argo Ave & Hancock St, Elmont, NY 11003

Reported 1 year ago, updated 2 months ago

CommunityKittn Unknown Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 71676271


Elmont, NY 11003

Gray, about five weeks old as of June 14, 2025.

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Francis Ct, between Argo Ave & Hancock St, Elmont, NY 11003

Reported 2 years ago, updated 2 months ago

CommunityCat #4 Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 71163448


Elmont, NY 11003

Black and white. TNR (left ear is clipped). He is now full grown. Picture was taken when he was younger.

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Allen Park, South Farmingdale, NY 11735

Reported 2 months ago

Giselle Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72946791


South Farmingdale, NY 11735

8lb female tabby cat with left ear clipped, about 6 years old

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Colonial Street, Elwood, NY 11731

Reported 2 months ago

Disney Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72944427


Elwood, NY 11731

Tabby

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen South 23rd Street and Brooklyn Ave, Wyandanch, NY 11798

Reported 12 months ago, updated 2 months ago

Benny Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 71833121


Wyandanch, NY 11798

Male Neutered, Black w/White Domestic Short Hair Wearing Collar and Tags, Microchipped

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Island 16 movies , horseblock rd, Holbrook, NY 11741

Reported 2 months ago

Nina Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72935184


Holbrook, NY 11741

Mix Siamese blue eye skinny long beige

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Alexan Blvd, Bellport, NY 11713

Reported 2 months ago

Paulie Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72932206


Bellport, NY 11713

Grey male, not neutered yet, yellowish-green eyes.. a little over a year old. Very sweet.

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Brentwood rd ,awixa ave , Saxon Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Reported 4 months ago, updated 2 months ago

Lulu Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72677464


Bay Shore, NY 11706

Mostly Black and white chest. Black mask , Diamond nose. tiny 7 lbs

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Off of Brentwood Rd., Bay Shore, NY 11706

Reported 2 months ago, updated 2 months ago

Tom Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72889765


Bay Shore, NY 11706

Adult, male, Tabby cat, friendly but won’t approach most people, average to slightly over weight, and a clipped ear

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen N 6th st and W John st, Lindenhurst, NY 11757

Reported 2 months ago

Finney Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72913510


Lindenhurst, NY 11757

Black and white tuxedo cat with green eyes

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Near Car repair shop, detroit street, Massapequa, NY 11758

Reported 2 months ago

ze Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72908870


Massapequa, NY 11758

Tuxedo

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Jericho Tpke/ First Ave, New Hyde Park, NY 11040

Reported 3 months ago, updated 2 months ago

Minnie Mouse Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72771330


New Hyde Park, NY 11040

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Nagle Ln, Central Islip, NY 11722

Reported 2 months ago, updated 2 months ago

Dorian Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72886377


Central Islip, NY 11722

All black with left ear tip.

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Hemlock drive locust dr riviera dr, Kings Park, NY 11754

Reported 2 months ago

Cheesecake Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72885250


Kings Park, NY 11754

Torti black cat with tan

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Ash and Merrick, Valley Stream, NY 11580

Reported 6 months ago, updated 2 months ago

Summer Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72480258


Valley Stream, NY 11580

White gray with a small tan patch heart shaped nose

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Metropolitan Ave 11710, North Bellmore, NY 11710

Reported 2 months ago

Mischief Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72879417


North Bellmore, NY 11710

Small skinny calico cat

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Near, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Reported 2 months ago

Ozzy Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72874549


Farmingdale, NY 11735

Black tuxedo, white paws. Pink/white nose

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Greystone and Gateway, Rockville Centre, NY 11570

Reported 2 months ago

Milo Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72860394


Rockville Centre, NY 11570

Orange tabby

View Pet

Lost Cat Data for Bay Shore, NY

There are 115 lost cats in Bay Shore, NY.

Find Local Cat Shelters in Bay Shore, NY

PawBoost has communities of cat-lovers across the country and beyond that help find missing cats, and that means partnerships with cat shelters in the US and in Canada.

Are you a team member at a shelter not yet partnered with PawBoost?

Request Shelter Partnership

Find Your Cat Sooner with PawBoost

When you have a missing cat, it can be difficult to know what to do in the moment.

How do I find my cat? Do I have to visit the cat shelters in my area in person, or is it okay to just call? How can I get the word out to my local community in Bay Shore?

With our free tools and premium add-on services, PawBoost helps lost cat owners find their furry loved ones – 2,268,751 pets reunited and counting!

Find your lost cat faster with PawBoost.

Report Lost Cat

Frequently Asked Questions

I lost my cat. What should I do?

Take advantage of online platforms – they help you get the word out, quickly and easily. You can report your lost cat to PawBoost in no time flat. We'll send an email alert to our local members, post to the PawBoost-powered Facebook page for your area, add your cat to our lost & found, and make a lost cat flyer – all for free.

Other sites that help you raise local awareness for your lost cat with minimal time and effort are Nextdoor.com – a PawBoost partner – and Craigslist. Both of these sites have very active lost & found sections mainly used for lost pets. We highly recommend you use these resources in addition to PawBoost!

Visit your local shelters and animal control agencies in person. Details can get lost in translation over the phone and that might lead to missed connection.

If chipped, make sure your cat's microchip is registered and up to date. If you don't know your pet's chip manufacturer or number, your vet should be able to help locate this information.

Put up flyers and tell your neighbors to be on the lookout. The more you engage the Bay Shore community, the better your chances of a happy reunion!

Read our full guide on how to find your lost cat for more actionable tips.

Where do I report a lost cat in Bay Shore, NY?

If you lost a cat, we would like to help. You can report a lost cat to PawBoost for free to help find your cat in the Bay Shore area. Millions of pet lovers have signed up for our local lost & found pet alerts, and that includes pet lovers near Bay Shore!

Do I have to pay for premium PawBoost services to find my lost cat?

You don't have to pay to find your lost pet with PawBoost. PawBoost's free cat finder services have helped millions of people reunite with their lost cats.

PawBoost does offer premium upgrades to help increase the reach of your lost pet alert.

You can learn more about what free and premium services PawBoost offers here.