PawBoost ID or Name

Status

Location

City, Zip, or Address
Distance

Animal

Type

Sex

Sort

Within Past

Lost Cats Database for Bay Shore, NY

Search lost and found cats, as well as other pets, in the Bay Shore area with PawBoost.

100 lost cats in your search

Lost Male Cat last seen Conifer Court, Northport, NY 11768

Reported 3 years ago, updated 8 hours ago

Batman Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 69411289


Northport, NY 11768

Small, Young, Dark Brown Marbled and White Male. Looks black and white at night, and from a distant. Called Batman because of the mask-like appearance over his eyes. Skittish, afraid of most people. He was a stray/feral who was being fed every night by me for seven months. He would only show up at night and he was always ravenous! I was in the process of socializing him, with the intent of getting him off the streets. Vanished from my front porch on July 29th, 2023 at 10:30 PM, while I ran inside the hse for a few minutes to get him his food and water. I have not seen him since?! I am beside myself with worry.

View Pet

Lost Unknown Cat last seen Francis Ct, between Argo Ave & Hancock St, Elmont, NY 11003

Reported 12 months ago, updated 9 hours ago

CommunityKittn Unknown Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 71676271


Elmont, NY 11003

Gray, about five weeks old as of June 14, 2025.

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Francis Ct, between Argo Ave & Hancock St, Elmont, NY 11003

Reported 1 year ago, updated 9 hours ago

CommunityCat #4 Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 71163448


Elmont, NY 11003

Black and white. TNR (left ear is clipped). He is now full grown. Picture was taken when he was younger.

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Weight Ave, Greis Park, Lynbrook, NY 11563

Reported 7 months ago, updated 13 hours ago

Kitty Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72182951


Lynbrook, NY 11563

All black, yellow eyes, short body

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen S main st freeport, Freeport, NY 11520

Reported 3 years ago, updated 2 days ago

Max Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 69283161


Freeport, NY 11520

Domestic shorthair,

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Jefferson and Campion St , Brentwood, NY 11717

Reported 6 years ago, updated 2 days ago

Toby Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 66643777


Brentwood, NY 11717

Large marble-like swirled tabby. Wearing a grey flea collar. Very friendly

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Near park avenue , Roosevelt, NY 11575

Reported 6 months ago, updated 2 days ago

Missy Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72323291


Roosevelt, NY 11575

Black and grey

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Port Ave , Ronkonkoma, NY 11749

Reported 3 years ago, updated 2 days ago

Winston Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 69731505


Ronkonkoma, NY 11749

White marking up right side of nose.

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Stanton Ave., Baldwin, NY 11510

Reported 2 months ago, updated 2 days ago

Pip Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72720985


Baldwin, NY 11510

Pip is a Tuxedo cat with a clipped left ear, a diagonal scratch across his nose, 2 white lines under his nose and a pure white chin and neck.

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Normandy Gardens apmts , Lindenhurst, NY 11757

Reported 4 days ago, updated 2 days ago

Midnight Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72950059


Lindenhurst, NY 11757

He's about 8 or nine now that's the only picture I have of him

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Connetquot Ave. and Bellmore Ave., Islip Terrace, NY 11752

Reported 3 days ago

Milo Ren Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72954695


Islip Terrace, NY 11752

Grey/Taupe and black tiger striped shorthaired Tabby cat.

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Wenmore Road and Bethany Drive, Commack, NY 11725

Reported 6 years ago, updated 3 days ago

Parker Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 66364658


Commack, NY 11725

Dark brown and light brown stripes, white paws, white chest area, white nose area, bright pink nose, and bright green eyes. Correct Phone number is (631)398-1889

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Pacific Street and Milburn Avenue, Baldwin, NY 11510

Reported 4 months ago, updated 3 days ago

Diablo Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72540414


Baldwin, NY 11510

Black and white cat with black nose and light blue collar

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen W John st, Hicksville, NY 11801

Reported 3 days ago

Molly Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72952728


Hicksville, NY 11801

Molly- gray and black striped tabby, white chin

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Near gull dip rd,  ridge ny 11961, Ridge, NY 11961

Reported 2 years ago, updated 3 days ago

Lucifer Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 70937151


Ridge, NY 11961

All black cat with extra toes on front paws.

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen Little Plains Rd and Broadway, Huntington, NY 11743

Reported 4 days ago

Soup Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72949144


Huntington, NY 11743

Black with green eyes and a white patch on fur on his chest

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Medford Lane and Klaibar Lane, East Northport, NY 11731

Reported 1 month ago, updated 4 days ago

Luna Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72789095


East Northport, NY 11731

Shorthair, white with black spots on face and back, black tail has a white tip

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Everett street , Lynbrook, NY 11563

Reported 6 days ago, updated 4 days ago

Khloe Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72940597


Lynbrook, NY 11563

Fluffy Tortie

View Pet

Lost Male Cat last seen stolen from motel room in his cage, Holtsville, NY 11742

Reported 3 weeks ago, updated 4 days ago

Fluffernutters Male Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72876709


Holtsville, NY 11742

Unneutered male

View Pet

Lost Female Cat last seen Lakeland Inn off Lakeland Avenue behind motel, Bohemia, NY 11716

Reported 3 weeks ago, updated 4 days ago

Emerald Female Cat

LOST PawBoost ID: 72876729


Bohemia, NY 11716

Neutered female calico cat with a emerald green eyes

View Pet

Lost Cat Data for Bay Shore, NY

There are 100 lost cats in Bay Shore, NY.

Find Local Cat Shelters in Bay Shore, NY

PawBoost has communities of cat-lovers across the country and beyond that help find missing cats, and that means partnerships with cat shelters in the US and in Canada.

Are you a team member at a shelter not yet partnered with PawBoost?

Request Shelter Partnership

Find Your Cat Sooner with PawBoost

When you have a missing cat, it can be difficult to know what to do in the moment.

How do I find my cat? Do I have to visit the cat shelters in my area in person, or is it okay to just call? How can I get the word out to my local community in Bay Shore?

With our free tools and premium add-on services, PawBoost helps lost cat owners find their furry loved ones – 2,229,080 pets reunited and counting!

Find your lost cat faster with PawBoost.

Report Lost Cat

Frequently Asked Questions

I lost my cat. What should I do?

Take advantage of online platforms – they help you get the word out, quickly and easily. You can report your lost cat to PawBoost in no time flat. We'll send an email alert to our local members, post to the PawBoost-powered Facebook page for your area, add your cat to our lost & found, and make a lost cat flyer – all for free.

Other sites that help you raise local awareness for your lost cat with minimal time and effort are Nextdoor.com – a PawBoost partner – and Craigslist. Both of these sites have very active lost & found sections mainly used for lost pets. We highly recommend you use these resources in addition to PawBoost!

Visit your local shelters and animal control agencies in person. Details can get lost in translation over the phone and that might lead to missed connection.

If chipped, make sure your cat's microchip is registered and up to date. If you don't know your pet's chip manufacturer or number, your vet should be able to help locate this information.

Put up flyers and tell your neighbors to be on the lookout. The more you engage the Bay Shore community, the better your chances of a happy reunion!

Read our full guide on how to find your lost cat for more actionable tips.

Where do I report a lost cat in Bay Shore, NY?

If you lost a cat, we would like to help. You can report a lost cat to PawBoost for free to help find your cat in the Bay Shore area. Millions of pet lovers have signed up for our local lost & found pet alerts, and that includes pet lovers near Bay Shore!

Do I have to pay for premium PawBoost services to find my lost cat?

You don't have to pay to find your lost pet with PawBoost. PawBoost's free cat finder services have helped millions of people reunite with their lost cats.

PawBoost does offer premium upgrades to help increase the reach of your lost pet alert.

You can learn more about what free and premium services PawBoost offers here.